Founding Attorney
Buying a horse is a significant investment, whether for competition, breeding, or recreational riding. Unfortunately, not all transactions go smoothly. If you purchased a horse that turned out to have undisclosed health issues, behavioral problems, or other defects, you may be wondering whether you have legal recourse.
In Wellington and West Palm Beach, buyers have legal options if they were misled or defrauded in a horse sale. This blog from Gueronniere, P.A. will help you understand your rights and the legal grounds for a lawsuit, which can help you determine the best course of action if you’ve been sold a “bad” horse.
Legal Grounds for Suing Over a Horse Sale
Whether you can sue the seller depends on the circumstances of the sale and whether there was misrepresentation, fraud, or breach of contract. Here are the primary legal claims that may apply:
Breach of Contract
If a written contract was involved in the horse sale, the terms of that contract will be the primary factor in determining your legal rights. A breach of contract may occur if:
- The seller failed to provide a horse that met the agreed-upon specifications (e.g., breed, training level, or health status).
- The horse was not delivered as promised.
- The seller included specific warranties in the contract that were not upheld.
Contracts often include clauses regarding health guarantees, soundness, and return policies. If the seller violated these terms, you may have a strong case for breach of contract.
Fraudulent Misrepresentation
Fraud occurs when a seller intentionally deceives a buyer about a material fact regarding the horse. This could include:
- Concealing known health issues or lameness.
- Misrepresenting the horse’s age, training, or competition history.
- Administering drugs to mask pain or behavioral issues during the sale process.
To succeed in a fraud claim, you must prove that the seller knowingly misled you and that you relied on their statements when making the purchase.
Negligent Misrepresentation
Unlike fraud, negligent misrepresentation does not require intent. Instead, it occurs when a seller provides false information about a horse without verifying its accuracy. Even if the seller did not intentionally deceive you, they can still be held liable if their statements led to financial loss.
Breach of Warranty
Some horse sales include express or implied warranties.
- Express Warranty: If the seller made specific guarantees about the horse’s condition, performance ability, or temperament, and those statements turned out to be false, they may have breached an express warranty.
- Implied Warranty: Even if no written warranty exists, Florida law may recognize an implied warranty if the seller claimed the horse was fit for a particular purpose (e.g., competition or breeding) and it was not.
If a warranty was breached, the buyer may be able to seek compensation or rescind the sale.
Violation of Florida’s Equine Disclosure Laws
Florida has laws requiring fair dealing in horse sales. For example, under Florida Statutes § 535.16, sellers must disclose material defects when selling a horse. Additionally, written agreements are required for certain transactions to prevent disputes over verbal promises.
Failure to comply with these laws can strengthen a buyer’s case if they were misled or defrauded in a sale.
Steps to Take if You Bought a “Bad” Horse
If you believe you were misled in a horse purchase, consider the following steps:
- Review Your Sales Agreement: Examine any contracts, warranties, or sale documents. Look for terms related to health guarantees, return policies, or dispute resolution.
- Gather Evidence: Document any issues with the horse, including veterinary reports, trainer assessments, and communication with the seller. If the seller made verbal assurances, try to obtain witness statements.
- Seek Veterinary and Legal Opinions: A veterinarian can provide expert analysis on whether the horse’s condition was pre-existing or misrepresented. An attorney can assess your legal options based on Florida law.
- Attempt Negotiation: In some cases, disputes can be resolved without litigation. You may be able to negotiate a refund, replacement, or settlement with the seller.
- File a Lawsuit if Necessary: If negotiations fail, you may have grounds for legal action. Remedies could include canceling the sale and getting a refund, recovering damages for vet costs or training expenses, or holding the seller accountable for fraud or misrepresentation
How Gueronniere Law, P.A. Can Help
Gueronniere Law, P.A. assists horse buyers in Wellington, West Palm Beach, and throughout Florida in resolving disputes related to horse sales. We provide legal guidance on reviewing and drafting equine sales contracts. Assessing fraud or misrepresentation claims, negotiating settlements and enforcing warranties, and even pursuing legal action for you when necessary. With extensive experience in equine law, our firm understands the complexities of horse transactions and how to protect your rights in a dispute.
Protect Yourself When Buying a Horse
To avoid legal disputes, buyers should take precautions when purchasing a horse, including:
- Requesting a Pre-Purchase Exam: Have a veterinarian conduct a thorough exam before finalizing the sale.
- Getting Everything in Writing: Document all information about the horse’s condition, training, and history.
- Working with Reputable Sellers: Conduct background checks and ask for references before purchasing a horse.
If you’ve purchased a horse that wasn’t as advertised, contact Gueronniere, P.A. today. We can help you explore your legal options and seek a fair resolution.